Ontario spending more on education but getting less

Ontarians could save up to $1.9 billion if the province reformed education spending

Download Ontario spending more on education but getting less

By Deani Van Pelt
and Jason Clemens
The Fraser Institute

VANCOUVER, BC, Apr 1, 2015/ Troy Media/ – The Ontario government of Kathleen Wynne will soon present its first budget since being re-elected with a majority in June 2014. This will be a critical test, particularly with respect to the bond market and credit rating agencies.

The governing Liberals must present a credible fiscal plan that, among other things, curbs government spending. And yet, unless the government targets its two largest spending portfolios – healthcare and education – It will be nearly impossible to restrain spending.

Spending more on education not always the answer

The key to mitigating spending restraint – or cuts – is to reform existing spending. Before discussing reform, however, it’s important to understand the current state of education spending.

Statistics Canada’s data between 2001-02 and 2011-12, the most recent years available, show spending on public schools in Ontario increased 62.4 per cent, from $15.2 billion to $24.8 billion. When price changes (inflation) are considered, the increase is 32.5 per cent. Only Alberta and Saskatchewan had higher increases in spending on public schools in that period.

spending more on education
Spending more on education self-defeating

This measure, however, does not account for changes in student enrolment, and therefore presents an incomplete picture of education spending. After all, if a jurisdiction increases education spending but simultaneously experiences a larger proportional increase in enrolment, actual per student spending will decline. Alternatively, a jurisdiction with a declining enrolment could actually reduce total education spending but still increase per student spending. A recent Fraser Institute study calculated the per student spending levels over the last decade.

In total, public school enrolment in Ontario dropped from 2.16 million in 2001-02 to 2.04 million in 2011-12, a 5.5 per cent decrease.

The declining enrolment amplifies the increase in Ontario public school spending. During the same 11-year period, spending on a per-student basis increased 72 per cent, from $7,047 to $12,117.

Yet dramatic increases in spending aren’t necessarily associated with increases in achievement. In Ontario, recent measurements of mathematics performance, for instance, by the Education Quality and Accountability Office show declines in the percentage of Grade 3 and Grade 6 pupils performing at or above the provincial standard. Specifically, only 54 per cent of Grade 6 pupils achieved at or above the provincial standard in math, down from 61 per cent five years ago.

Study after study has demonstrated that it’s far more important to focus on how money is spent rather than worrying about the total amount spent. The key to better education isn’t spending more – it’s spending wisely, reforming the way we spend.

British Columbia offers a model for reform in Ontario. B.C. enjoys comparatively low levels of spending increases coupled with relatively high student performance rankings (as measured in 2012 by OECD’s PISA scores).

Unlike Ontario, B.C. relies heavily on parental choice and education competition with one-in-eight students attending an independent school. Ontario, uniquely in Canada, relies on four public systems of education, thus providing parents with limited choice. Only one-in-20 Ontario students attend an independent school.

A 2014 Fraser Institute study estimated that Ontarians could save up to $1.9 billion if the province reformed education spending by adopting a B.C.-style model for education.

Spending more on education hasn’t improved results

As Ontario’s government prepares to deliver its budget, it’s important to note that, contrary to the rhetoric, spending on public schools in Ontario has increased dramatically. And more spending hasn’t meant better results.

The focus should be on reform – how we spend on education – and not on simply worrying about the amount we spend.

Deani Van Pelt is Director of the Barbara Mitchell Centre for Improvement in Education. Jason Clemens is Executive Vice President at the Fraser Institute.

THIS CONTENT IS FREE to use in your publication or on your website. Download now.

Troy Media Marketplace © 2015 – All Rights Reserved
Trusted editorial content provider to media outlets across Canada

Click here to report a typo or inaccuracy

Submit a Letter to the Editor

0

One Response to "Ontario spending more on education but getting less"

  1. Diogenes37   June 3, 2015 at 9:06 am

    Hmm.  I wonder what has happened to your christmas gift expenditiure in the same time frame.  Cell phones, computers, tablets, software, repairs, replacement etc. have changed an average 8 year old’s demands exponentially.  Don’t forget that to keep up the illusion of progress, schools have had to play ball with this.  Now we have 8 computers per class in the school, numerous full time IT specialists hired to keep them working, and hours of PD and workshops to prepare teachers for the incessant changes.  In five years I personally have had 4 different computers (2 desktop, 2 tablets) without asking for a change.  I’d like to see data on how much all this is costing.  The data I have seen is on a different topic, but Mark Bauerlein as well as Fuchs and Woesmann et. al.  have been pretty convincing in their research suggesting that COMPUTERS DON’T IMPROVE STUDENT LEARNING.  What a waste.

You must be logged in to post a comment Login