COP21 is irrelevant and should be cancelled

The real action on how we will live, eat and travel taking place during free trade negotiations

Download this column on COP21 for your publication or website. FREE TRIAL
Terms and Conditions of use
Contact Stephen

EDMONTON, AB Oct 14, 2015/ Troy Media/ – The final stages of preparation for COP 21, the Paris climate change talks, are still underway, but all is not well in the world of the national climate change management negotiators.

Preliminary negotiations have made clear that there will be no legally-binding agreement on CO2 emissions and it will be difficult to secure agreement on reparations for developing nations seeking an annual fund of $100 billion to invest in energy projects to make affordable, low emissions technology available to them.

The EU will not support a deal that is not legally binding on all 200 nations participating in the talks. India and China will not accept a deal that inhibits their energy strategies, which depend largely on fossil fuels (especially coal). Most developing nations are focused on the creation of a global fund and, if this does not materialize at the funding level they expect, will object to other aspects of any climate change deal. All of the offers of CO2 cuts made to date will also not “stop” climate change reaching more than 2C by 2100 – the arbitrary target chosen to guide these discussions. Things look bleak.

But then this is all a very silly idea. The idea that the 10,000+ people who will gather for COP21 in Paris in December can “stop climate change” is in itself nonsense. The climate is a complex business with many different factors playing a role in shaping the way in which climate plays out in the regions of the world. Yes, man-made CO2 is a part of the climate system, but it is a small part and many climate scientists remain unsure of the extent to which climate is sensitive to CO2 and what the contribution of this man-made proportion of CO2 (which also comes from other sources) plays in such a complex system. There is no simple correlation (i.e. increases in CO2 lead automatically to increases in global mean surface temperature) and a relentless focus on this one variable is now a part of the problem as well as part of the work that needs to be done.

It would be much better for the COP21 delegates to focus on the implications of inequality in the world and the way in which modern capitalism works – the issue that is really at the heart of these talks, which are really all about the right of all people to live a decent, secure life with access to affordable shelter, energy, food and economic security. These are all seen to be threatened by current modes of economic and social development as symbolized by CO2 emissions.

The secret negotiations between governments and representatives of the richest people in the world for so-called “free trade” deals, like the Trans-Pacific Partnership and the EU-U.S. Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership deal (TTIP), will have an impact on what we eat, how we travel, how we live our lives and how nations live together (or not). It is those negotiations – which many do not connect with climate change or energy development – that will have more impact on the environment, climate, oceans and energy strategy than the meetings in Paris. Yet the details of these talks are secret – only the negotiators, a strictly limited number of government ministers and a legion of lobbyists – know them. Maybe we should cancel the Paris climate change talks, which will go nowhere, and instead refuse to meet until the full details of the TPP and TTIP are released and their environmental impacts assessed.

As I mentioned before in a previous column, the real issue under discussion at COP21 is the future of capitalism for all. That is, equity is the real issue.

Stephen Murgatroyd is a consultant in innovative business and education practices with a PHd in psychology.

Troy Media Marketplace © 2015 – All Rights Reserved
Trusted editorial content provider to media outlets across Canada
Terms and Conditions of use Get Help FAQ

FROM THE EDITOR: Troy Media has decided to discontinue allowing anonymous comments. Please Submit a Letter to the Editor

[contact-form-7 id=”80428″ title=”Letter to the Editor”]


You must be logged in to post a comment Login