Why don’t Canadian broadcasters love the beautiful game?

Being a true football fan in Canada has been a pretty lonely existence

Reading Time: 4 minutes

Peter MenziesThirty-six years ago last week, the Calgary Flames scored one of their most famous triumphs – a 3-2 Game 7 playoff victory over the defending Stanley Cup champion Edmonton Oilers.

Back then I was sports editor of the Calgary Sun, and that playoff run to the finals (Calgary lost to Montreal in five games) consumed my days and nights. But I was secretly just as excited that, by June, I’d be in Mexico covering Canada’s debut at World Cup ’86.

In Canada, being a true football fan has been a pretty lonely, often mocked, existence. Sports departments considered soccer merely “an immigrant’s game” about which “no one cared” and that “would never catch on.” Depressing stuff for those in love with the game.

Although there are now four registered Canadian soccer players for every hockey player, little has changed. Just last year, in-house footy experts such as Craig Forrest and Kristian Jack were shown the door at TSN and – outside of the Olympics or World Cup finals – you couldn’t pay Bell Media or Rogers/Sportsnet to broadcast a Canadian national team game. Well, you could, but that was the only way they’d do it.

RELATED CONTENT
Phil Mickelson wins one for the ages
By Michael Taube
 
Greed drives pro golfers to align with Saudi sportswashers
By Ken Reed
 
How soccer revitalizes nationalism
By Bruce Dowbiggin

MORE IN SPORTS

Other people saw opportunity and paid attention to the fact that Canada, along with the United States and Mexico, would host the men’s World Cup in 2026. They looked into the future and saw that, within 10 years, the beautiful game could become Canada’s second – at worst, third – most popular sport, and they were willing to invest in domestic and international games. Thanks to a long-term partnership with online streamer OneSoccer, the Canadian Premier League launched in 2019.

Turns out they were on to something. Pandemic disruptions opened a door for Canada’s men to qualify for the 2022 World Cup and, lo and behold, they charged right through it. They muscled their way past Caribbean minnows last spring before squeezing into the final group with the big fish. A strong showing in July’s Gold Cup hinted that forces that can’t be explained may be at play.

And then the national women’s team, twice broken-hearted bronze medalists, won Olympic gold in Tokyo. CBC recorded an audience of 4.4 million people for the final. Eyebrows were raised.

So it came as no surprise that, when the men’s team resumed its run in September, Sportsnet made a deal with OneSoccer. Suddenly there was full coverage – online and broadcast. Eyeballs multiplied. Home games sold out in minutes. By March, a combined audience of almost two million (average Canadian Football League audiences last year were a shade under 500,000) watched as Canada became the nation’s feel-good story of the year by clinching first place in their region and qualifying ahead of the U.S., Mexico and five other countries.

And then it just stopped. World Cup rights-holder Bell Media confirmed TSN would cover Canada at the finals in Qatar in November and December but, otherwise, it’s as if the past 10 euphoric months never happened.

Over the protests of icons such as Stephanie Labbe and Christine Sinclair, the women’s gold medal “celebration tour” was shrugged off. She might be the GOAT, but except for Telus there was no cable TV audience for Sinclair and her teammates. Canada’s licensed broadcasting system appeared content to return Canadian women to oblivion.

That means ignoring the national women’s senior and U-17 teams in World Cup and Olympic qualification tournaments, the Canadian Premier League, the men’s Nation’s League and World Cup tune-ups featuring global stars such as Alphonso Davies and Jonathan David – players with transfer market values estimated at $108 million and $67.5 million respectively.

Nothing quite says Canadian broadcasting like the fact that I can watch Canadian Premier League soccer on Fox Sports in the United States, Mexico or the United Kingdom, but I can’t watch it on Shaw cable in Medicine Hat.

I can watch English Women’s Super League games before crowds of 3,000 in Birmingham on Sportsnet, but I can’t watch Canadian women play at home in front of crowds of 20,000 in Vancouver.

Or that Canadian TV subscribers could watch the German Bundesliga, Spain’s LaLiga or the Columbus Crew versus D.C. United last weekend but couldn’t watch the Halifax Wanderers home opener against FC Edmonton.

It’s a beautiful game. The Canadians who play it are respected globally but still not, it appears, within their own country where, ironically, the main purpose of its regulated broadcasting system is to promote Canadian content.

It’s time that Canada learned to love itself.

Peter Menzies is a Senior Fellow with the Macdonald-Laurier Institute and writes on communication matters and advises tech companies, including Top Notch Studios/OneSoccer. This commentary originally appeared in Cartt.ca and is republished with permission. 

Peter is a Troy Media Thought Leader. For interview requests, click here.


The opinions expressed by our columnists and contributors are theirs alone and do not inherently or expressly reflect the views of our publication.

© Troy Media
Troy Media is an editorial content provider to media outlets and its own hosted community news outlets across Canada.

Peter Menzies

Peter Menzies spent three decades as a working journalist and newspaper executive, most notably with the Calgary Herald where he served as its editorial page editor, editor in chief and, finally, publisher.
Following his newspaper career, he spent close to 10 years as a member of the Canadian Radio-television Commission, initially in a part-time capacity followed by four years as regional commissioner for Alberta and the Northwest Territories and then four more as Vice-Chair of Telecommunications.
In the past, he has consulted on educational and media projects with the Fraser Institute and wrote frequently on media matters and the impact of the Internet on society during his time as a Senior Fellow with the think tank Cardus. Following the conclusion of his time with the CRTC, he resumed writing regular commentary for Troy Media through which his work has been published in the Victoria Times-Colonist, Winnipeg Free Press, Hamilton Spectator, Halifax Chronicle Herald and many others. He also writes on media and communications issues regularly for Convivium Magazine, The Globe & Mail, National Post and Toronto Star and advises tech companies.

One Response to "Why don’t Canadian broadcasters love the beautiful game?"

  1. Phil Cottrell   May 5, 2022 at 10:24 am

    Terrific article Right on the button. Why don’t they like the beautiful game? Because they are boneheaded, biased and living in the past? And for that matter what does the Canadian soccer Association do to help the game? Where are the Christine Sinclair shirts, where is the … we are off to the World Cup…. swag? All very well to have the soccer games on the One soccer pay channel, but that does nothing to spread the appeal of the sport in this country. It would be like asking me to buy a subscription to the golf channel when I don’t golf. I could vent like this forever.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.