A chance to give Canada’s North real communication service

But will the CRTC take advantage of the appointment of Claire Anderson to pursue significant change?

Reading Time: 4 minutes

It sounds a little bit like a Jack London novel but it’s true: I was sitting in the bar of the Gold Rush Inn in Whitehorse one day with a buddy when the barmaid asked what two old birds like us were doing in town.

Looking around and being careful not to be overheard, we confessed that we worked for the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission (CRTC) – not something you generally say out loud, particularly in the Land of the Midnight Sun.

“Are you the guys who opened the North up to competition?” she asked, much to our surprise.

We exchanged nervous glances and hesitantly replied, “Uh, ya, that’s us.”

Beaming with delight, she leaned over the bar, said “Thank you” and planted a kiss on my travelling companion’s cheek.

That’s one of the better stories I’ve about the commission. I use it not to illustrate how easy it is to make a pair of older gentlemen blush in a Yukon pub but to highlight the fact that there are some places in the country where communications policies aren’t taken for granted.

The largest part of that is the North, where about 113,000 Canadians are scattered across a frozen landscape about the size of western Europe. More than half the population – which is about one person for every 31 square km – is Indigenous. There are 12 official languages from Inuktitut to Dene, English and French.

Its communications infrastructure ranges from the Alaska border in the west to the North Atlantic off the coast of Baffin Island and from 60 to 83 degrees latitude. That’s the same distance as the United States between the southern tip of Florida and the 49th parallel. There are only about four roads – two including a seasonal ice road through Alberta to the Northwest Territories, one connecting Yukon to the Pacific coast at Skagway and the Alaska Highway south to B.C.

Its needs are enormous but when it comes to serving them, no one outside of the North really cares. Not when there are fights to be settled over whether 100 mbps Wi-Fi is available in vote-rich condo buildings in Toronto and Vancouver.

Those inside the territories – governments, consumers, Northwestel, SSI Micro and a handful of others – care a lot.

CRTC’s newest commissioner Claire Anderson
Claire Anderson
CRTC’s newest commissioner

The entire North will now be looking to the CRTC’s newest commissioner, Claire Anderson, to be its champion – whether she and the CRTC like it or not. Her appointment as the B.C.-Yukon regional commissioner was announced on July 5.

A lawyer, she is also a citizen of the Taku River Tlingit First Nation and on all the kind of boards an ambitious young person should be on. She is obviously smart and articulate.

She will be shocked to learn that CRTC commissioners are expected to do very little these days. Over the past decade, assignments to hearings have declined from six to eight annually to maybe one or two. Or less. There’s scant evidence that travel within their regions to gain awareness of issues or consumer perspectives is a priority. More and more decisions are paper processes essentially made by staff.

It would be tragic if the opportunity Anderson represents to the commission is wasted.

Hopefully, the absurd insistence upon commissioners living within 100 km of the regional office (in this case, Vancouver) has been tossed aside. Both the North and the commission badly need a member who lives in the North.

So they better give her more to do – and money to do it – rather than take a seven-hour journey each way to Ottawa five or six times a year in order to be put on display at a two-hour meeting.

Yes, some will criticize her appointment by noting she hasn’t a lick of experience in either the broadcasting or telecommunications worlds.

But she’ll definitely know the issue that matters: if southern Canada really wants to declare itself #wethenorth, it better get off its entitled urban backside and give the North the sort of modern communications network the United States gives Alaska and Denmark gives Greenland. Now.

Peter Menzies is a former newspaper publisher and vice-chair of the CRTC, and advises tech companies on regulatory policy (the views here are his own).

© Troy Media

The views, opinions and positions expressed by columnists and contributors are the author’s alone. They do not inherently or expressly reflect the views, opinions and/or positions of our publication.

Peter Menzies

Peter Menzies spent three decades as a working journalist and newspaper executive, most notably with the Calgary Herald where he served as its editorial page editor, editor in chief and, finally, publisher.
Following his newspaper career, he spent close to 10 years as a member of the Canadian Radio-television Commission, initially in a part-time capacity followed by four years as regional commissioner for Alberta and the Northwest Territories and then four more as Vice-Chair of Telecommunications.
In the past, he has consulted on educational and media projects with the Fraser Institute and wrote frequently on media matters and the impact of the Internet on society during his time as a Senior Fellow with the think tank Cardus. Following the conclusion of his time with the CRTC, he resumed writing regular commentary for Troy Media through which his work has been published in the Victoria Times-Colonist, Winnipeg Free Press, Hamilton Spectator, Halifax Chronicle Herald and many others. He also writes on media and communications issues regularly for Convivium Magazine, The Globe & Mail, National Post and Toronto Star and advises tech companies.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.