Getting down and dirty to block passage of bill whose aim is to improve health care for all British Columbians
Something different is happening in the usually staid, stable and predictable politics of British Columbia. It is happening in the tony Vancouver neighbourhood of West Point Grey. It is a loud, colourful and somewhat chaotic demonstration with the goal of collecting enough signatures on a petition to remove NDP premier David Eby from office.
In a democracy like Canada’s, we have the right and the ability to remove any politicians we want.
We just have to wait until the next election to do so. However, the assemblage of people supporting Eby’s recall does not want to wait that long. They have set themselves up to collect over 16,000 signatures from registered voters in the riding so that a referendum on Eby’s removal can occur.
Since financial support, interest, and even knowledge of this unusual activity is limited, the chances of getting a referendum, let alone having it succeed in ousting Eby, are slim. Who are the people doing this, and why are they putting their time and effort into such a long shot?
|Canada’s health-care system desperately needs creative leadership
|Haisla Chief frustrated waiting on regulatory decision for Cedar LNG
|Private facilities bring much needed competition to health care system
|Keep an Eye on BC
The demonstrators are a motley crew, as Vancouver Sun columnist Daphne Bramham has pointed out. The anti-vaxxers are out in force, as are those who oppose just about any government or politicians on principle. They are joined by wild extremists who believe in things like putting to death journalists who lie. This could have some interesting consequences given the ideas of ‘truth’ many of these folk espouse.
More recently, the recallers have been joined by large groups more likely to be considered the pillars of society than those who are trying to knock those pillars down. These are members of the various health professions and their associations.
The reason doctors, nurses and others who work in health care are getting down and dirty in this grassroots demonstration is the Health Professions and Occupations Act (HOPA), often referred to as Bill 36, which the BC’s NDP government has introduced.
HOPA will replace existing independent professional health-care associations with bodies controlled by the new act. Until now, professional associations were independent member-controlled bodies operating, among other things, in the interests of the members. The new organizations will be government-controlled regulatory bodies and have as their primary mandate to ensure that they are acting in the best interests of the public – not an unreasonable government function.
BC’s NDP government has followed this pattern before. Since 2018 several non-health-related professional bodies, such as those for engineers, agrologists and technicians, have been brought under the Professional Governance Act (PGA), turning them from member supporting organizations into regulatory bodies whose main function is ensuring that the public is well served.
Most people have felt that the public interest has not been badly served by the professionals now under the PGA. The same cannot be said about health care. As is widely recognized and as I have noted before, the health care situation in BC is not meeting the needs of the public. One (and only one) reason for the shortfall is the lack of sufficient medical personnel, including physicians and nurses.
Contributing to the shortages are the very high standards that health professional associations have set for entrants into the profession, especially those trained outside BC. This is presumably to ensure that only well-qualified people are treating the citizens of British Columba. However, the net is now set so wide that it excludes well-trained people with experience in some of the best medical centres and hospitals in the world.
One might be forgiven for wondering whether the current practices also have as a goal to limit the supply of doctors, nurses, etc., to ensure that their scarcity results in higher incomes. Fewer medical staff offering less health care is definitely not in the best interests of British Columbians. Nor, other things being equal, is higher wages.
HOPA could well be a step to increasing the supply of available health care so desperately needed by many British Columbians. We should be supporting the government in its efforts to provide us, the public, with more and better health care, not trying to remove the premier who is shepherding this bill through. Of course, if we do not like the premier, we are blessed with the right to give him the boot at the next election.
Dr. Roslyn Kunin is president of the Vancouver Institute and has been chair of the Vancouver Stock Exchange, WorkSafe BC, and Haida Enterprise Corporation. She has also been on the boards of the Business Development Bank of Canada (BDC) and the National Statistics Council.
For interview requests, click here.
The opinions expressed by our columnists and contributors are theirs alone and do not inherently or expressly reflect the views of our publication.
© Troy Media
Troy Media is an editorial content provider to media outlets and its own hosted community news outlets across Canada.
Bill 36 HPOA essentially is attempting to gag Drs and punish them for expressing options contrary to those that the government approves. This law will likely also cover other aspects of health care including Physio massage and chiropractic care.
It gives power to the Minister to appoint the college boards which then leads to:
Imposed vaccination requirements under their authority for anything the government deems necessary
Impose proof of up-to-date status of vaccination for licensing
Board will dismiss without notice or a hearing when proof is not provided
If any health worker speaks out or does not comply they may lose their license
If an individual has made a false statement again as determined by the government, may enter into their property to search copy or seize under sect 506
Change the locks under sect 511
Done them to $200,000 under sect 518 1 a c
This law restrains all normal democratic functions back to an Orwellian system
This law will not grow the health-care system but will threaten to harm the system by creating even further shortages
Need to ensure practitioners’ rights are protected otherwise we will see them retire or move to areas where their rights are protected
In future please have your contributors print the whole truth to a story
Tell both sides.
Don’t go along with BS