When looking at balance sheets, the evidence of “greedflation” is weak at best
Let’s get one thing out of the way. Having CEOs of major grocery chains showing up in Ottawa on March 8 to testify before the Standing Parliamentary Committee on Agriculture is nothing more than political theatre. Not much will be accomplished. Still, for the sake of Canadians, CEOs needed to show their faces.
Hardly anyone will know the names of the other two CEOs, Michael Medline and Eric La Flèche. The real face of the entire industry, not just for Loblaws, is Galen Weston, who will likely be testifying in Ottawa for the first time. He is the face most Canadians see daily on television and hears on the radio, and he has become the lightning rod of consumer frustration at the grocery checkout.
It didn’t matter if other grocers have raised prices to the same extent as Loblaws or even that Canada’s food inflation remains the third lowest amongst G7 countries, including the EU. The blame was mostly and unfairly directed at one company, one man. It’s been a little silly.
Food inflation is inherently a global phenomenon, mainly affected by supply chain woes, energy costs, higher commodity prices and climate change. The United Kingdom, the sixth richest country in the world, is experiencing food shortages in many parts of the country. In comparison, Canada’s situation is not all that bad.
|Grocery receipt mistakes costing Canadians plenty
|Accusing grocers of “greedflation” is pointless, but…
|The world is running out of oil – vegetable oil
Furthermore, when looking at balance sheets, the evidence of “greedflation” is weak at best. Operating margins for all grocers in Canada have remained overall within the realm of acceptability, between 4.3 and 6.1 percent. Métro has the highest at 6.16 percent. Loblaws’ food sales last quarter increased by 8.4 percent, which is below our nation’s food inflation rate.
What’s driving sales and profits higher are most non-food categories like cosmetics, prescription drugs, and clothing. The morality of high profits on clothing or lipstick is far different than when food is involved, and it needs to be underscored.
But most Canadians, or politicians, don’t bother looking at balance sheets or at any data for that matter. Food inflation has been incredibly politicized, and skepticism has only grown as a result, especially in the last 12 months or so.
Still, the Canadian public has every right to be cynical about the grocery business. The bread price-fixing scheme became the symbol of corporate arrogance in the sector. After breaking the law for 14 years, Loblaws and executives were granted immunity by a branch of the federal government, the Competition Bureau. The investigation is still ongoing after almost eight years.
Some have speculated that collusion or price-fixing may have influenced other food categories, like meat packaging and salmon. Still, nothing has been investigated. Some abuse may exist in the food industry, but getting conclusive evidence has been nearly impossible. Canadians feel unprotected due to lingering unfinished inquiries.
Beyond the political artifice, the right questions must be asked if the session with CEOs is to be worthwhile. For one, CEOs need to be clear about how much profit is explicitly generated from food sales. Some questions about the “blackout” period are also warranted. From November to February, grocers have historically not accepted price increases from vendors. Some have argued vendors will routinely boost prices before and after the blackout period, which, to some degree, could open the field up to some price-fixing in the industry. Hard to see how consumers can win with these industry-wide practices going on.
The other issue is our food distribution competitive landscape. We have lost plenty of independent grocers over the years in Canada. Even though operating margins have remained stable in the grocery business in Canada, they are double those in the United States (The operating margin measures how much profit a company makes on a dollar of sales after paying for variable costs of production, such as wages and raw materials, but before paying interest or tax). Kroger’s and Albertson’s are barely at two percent. How to make our retail food industry more competitive should be top of mind for committee members.
As a result, many believe the newly introduced grocer code of conduct will help the industry become more competitive. The idea of the code is to counter the immense power some grocers have and bring more bargaining fairness for independent grocers and food manufacturers. The government-coordinated, industry-led code is being implemented right now. CEOs need to be clear on whether they support the initiative or not. Canadians would undoubtedly gain from a forceful, authoritative code.
But the harsh reality in Canada is this: for years, Canadians have had an uneasy relationship with the concept of competition. We loathe monopolies and oligopolies, even if many of them are driven by government policy. We want more control, that is until retail prices become an issue. Many sectors have been impacted by this: banking, telecoms, airlines. The list goes on. But for food retailing, the margin of error is nil. We need to get it right.
Canadian grocers are just one part of a much larger picture. Canada is not all that attractive to external investors unless you’re Walmart or Target, and we know what happened with Target in 2015. Its exit was brutal. Higher labour costs, a lower productivity rate, higher taxes, lopsided regulations between provinces, interprovincial trade barriers, and our country’s geographical vastness just adds more underappreciated complexity to the issue of competitiveness. Both Lidl and Aldi, major discount grocers, have flirted with the idea of investing in Canada for years, but the economics of food distribution barely makes sense for an expansion northward, at least for now.
For months, Canadians have criticized and even attacked grocers, blaming them for their misfortunes at the grocery store. As unpopular as it may be right now, that line of reasoning is as linear as it is unsophisticated. The “greedflation” nonsense is simply not helping.
Grocers will show up in Ottawa before the committee. The least we can do now is calm down and listen to what they have to say.
Dr. Sylvain Charlebois is senior director of the agri-food analytics lab and a professor in food distribution and policy at Dalhousie University.
For interview requests, click here.
© Troy Media
Troy Media is an editorial content provider to media outlets and its own hosted community news outlets across Canada.